Discussion:
motor question
(too old to reply)
Peter Fairbrother
2018-02-19 22:21:00 UTC
Permalink
My new Boxford has a three-phase motor, rated 380V in star mode and 220V
in mesh mode.

I don't have 3 phase, so do I:

a) buy a new single-phase motor or

b) buy an inverter. Can I use an inverter from 230V mains? What is mesh
mode? How to wire it?

The costs are about the same. I don't think there is a lot to be gained
from the speed control of the inverter, changing gear seems quick and easy.


Peter Fairbrother
Gareth's Downstairs Computer
2018-02-19 22:32:50 UTC
Permalink
Post by Peter Fairbrother
My new Boxford has a three-phase motor, rated 380V in star mode and 220V
in mesh mode.
a) buy a new single-phase motor  or
b) buy an inverter. Can I use an inverter from 230V mains? What is mesh
mode? How to wire it?
The costs are about the same. I don't think there is a lot to be gained
from the speed control of the inverter, changing gear seems quick and easy.
There's a guy who regularly advertises in homeworkshop.org.uk, Gavin
Oseman, in Malvern ISTR, 2 to 3 phase converters to run off 220V

In mesh mode, you wire each winding ends to form a triangle with no
neutral, if you see what I mean?
e***@whidbey.com
2018-02-19 22:54:41 UTC
Permalink
On Mon, 19 Feb 2018 22:21:00 +0000, Peter Fairbrother
Post by Peter Fairbrother
My new Boxford has a three-phase motor, rated 380V in star mode and 220V
in mesh mode.
a) buy a new single-phase motor or
b) buy an inverter. Can I use an inverter from 230V mains? What is mesh
mode? How to wire it?
The costs are about the same. I don't think there is a lot to be gained
from the speed control of the inverter, changing gear seems quick and easy.
Peter Fairbrother
Greetings Peter,
Get the inverter. One advantage of an inverter is the ability to
change speed while turning. This can be especially helpful if the tool
is chattering. The speed can be dialed in to stop the chatter.
It also help in facing cuts. The speed can be increased as the tool
approaches center, or decreased if facing away from the center. This
tends to keep the surface speed closer to constant which can lead to
better surface finishes and longer tool life.
Another advantage, if the inverter can handle it, is instant
reverse, which is great for power tapping. I do a lot of power
tapping.
There is a slight disadvantage with the inverter and it is a wiring
problem. You must turn on the motor with the inverter switch and
reverse the motor with the inverter. A good solution is to use the
lathe switch gear to do this. Disconnect the switch gear from the
lathe and connect it to the inverter.
And it is probably easier to change the wiring than it is to change
the motor timewise.
Eric
Richard Stearn
2018-02-20 09:55:47 UTC
Permalink
Post by e***@whidbey.com
Another advantage, if the inverter can handle it, is instant
reverse, which is great for power tapping. I do a lot of power
tapping.
Just remember you have a threaded nose lathe.
The spindle will reverse, the chuck might not.
Not saying don't, just be ready for the time the chuck doesn't
reverse.
houstonceng
2018-02-21 16:12:38 UTC
Permalink
The capacitor trick to run a 3phase motor ion simpngoe phase is the basis of the many converters sold. Most have an auto transformer to convert the 230v to 380v so that you can run the 3 phase motor in star mode and duel speed motors. An inverter won’t run a duel speed motor witored in star. If you want to try the capacitor converter, it’s best to run a pilot motor of twice the hp of the machine motor and chose the cap sizes accordingly. Then, when you connect the machine motor to the pilot you stand a better chance if having near balanced phases.

In most modern 3 phase motors, there are 6 terminals labelled U1, U2, V1, V2, W1 and W2 connected by links. For star, the links are usually connected in a line, thus joining U2, to V2 to W2. For delta (aka Mesh) the links are placed in parallel so that U2 connects to V1, V2 connects to W1 and W2 connects to U1.

If you run a pilot motor on a converter, or using your own selected capacitors, the set-up is called a rotary converter and you then connect your machine motor U, V and W to the pilot U, V and W respectively.

There is a lot of info on how to find the value of caps and diagrams. Personally, I find the inverter route the best.
e***@whidbey.com
2018-02-21 17:12:03 UTC
Permalink
On Wed, 21 Feb 2018 08:12:38 -0800 (PST), houstonceng
The capacitor trick to run a 3phase motor ion simpngoe phase is the basis of the many converters sold. Most have an auto transformer to convert the 230v to 380v so that you can run the 3 phase motor in star mode and duel speed motors. An inverter won’t run a duel speed motor witored in star. If you want to try the capacitor converter, it’s best to run a pilot motor of twice the hp of the machine motor and chose the cap sizes accordingly. Then, when you connect the machine motor to the pilot you stand a better chance if having near balanced phases.
In most modern 3 phase motors, there are 6 terminals labelled U1, U2, V1, V2, W1 and W2 connected by links. For star, the links are usually connected in a line, thus joining U2, to V2 to W2. For delta (aka Mesh) the links are placed in parallel so that U2 connects to V1, V2 connects to W1 and W2 connects to U1.
If you run a pilot motor on a converter, or using your own selected capacitors, the set-up is called a rotary converter and you then connect your machine motor U, V and W to the pilot U, V and W respectively.
There is a lot of info on how to find the value of caps and diagrams. Personally, I find the inverter route the best.
Where I live getting three phase power was excessively expensive,
even for a commercial shop. I would have had to pay $15,000.00 just
for the wire back in 1997. And I wouldn't have owned the wire. So I
use a big rotary phase converter to power my shop. But most of my
machines have inverter drives connected to the rotary converter.
Variable speed is really important to a commercial shop. Even if I had
three phase coming into the shop most machines would still have
inverter drives on them. Inverter drives are also known as VFDs. One
lathe has a 15 HP spindle and it "instantly" reverses when spinning at
5000 RPM. It slows and reverses very fast. It does this by dumping the
rotational energy back into the incoming power line. A mill I have
with a 10 HP spindle also reverses very fast, which is good for power
tapping, which is the only way I tap on that machine. But it dumps the
rotational energy into heating coils, just like you would find on a
stove top.
Eric
Peter Fairbrother
2018-02-21 19:01:39 UTC
Permalink
On 21/02/18 16:12, houstonceng wrote:
[..]
Post by houstonceng
In most modern 3 phase motors, there are 6 terminals labelled U1, U2, V1, V2, W1 and W2 connected by links. For star, the links are usually connected in a line, thus joining U2, to V2 to W2. For delta (aka Mesh) the links are placed in parallel so that U2 connects to V1, V2 connects to W1 and W2 connects to U1.
Ah, mesh == delta. I was wondering about that.

This motor has only three output wires, plain white, unlabelled. It says
220V mesh or 380V star on the plate. I think it was connected to 380V
3-phase before, but I'm not sure.

If I get a 220V inverter, how do I wire it up?


Thanks,

-- Peter Fairbrother
David Billington
2018-02-21 19:55:27 UTC
Permalink
Post by Peter Fairbrother
[..]
Post by houstonceng
In most modern 3 phase motors, there are 6 terminals labelled U1, U2,
V1, V2, W1 and W2 connected by links.  For star, the links are
usually connected in a line, thus joining U2, to V2 to W2.  For delta
(aka Mesh) the links are placed in parallel so that U2 connects to
V1, V2 connects to  W1 and W2 connects to U1.
Ah, mesh == delta. I was wondering about that.
This motor has only three output wires, plain white, unlabelled. It
says 220V mesh or 380V star on the plate. I think it was connected to
380V 3-phase before, but I'm not sure.
If I get a 220V inverter, how do I wire it up?
Thanks,
-- Peter Fairbrother
Wire it delta for 220V operation. I've ordered a number of bits from
these guys https://inverterdrive.com/ and found the service good. The
inverter package I bought used an ABB inverter and it came with a
comprehensive programming manual and was easily programmed from the
front panel as I suspect most are these days. I suspect the days of
having to use a proprietary external programming unit are gone
fortunately and the inverter prices seem to have come way down.
houstonceng
2018-02-21 20:19:08 UTC
Permalink
When you say it has three wires coming out, are these actual wires out of the terminal box on the motor, or the number of wires inside the terminal box. Irrespective of the way the motor is configured, Star or Delta, there are normally only three wires connecting the wind8ngs and, there should be, an earth wire as well.
houstonceng
2018-02-21 21:46:17 UTC
Permalink
Peter

After the motor has been connected in Delta, you have three wires out of the Inverter (aka VFD) each one of 2hich connect to one pint on the Delta giving 230v per phase. The 240 live and neutral supply is connected to the inverter, usually to thermoplastic marked L1and L2. The Control wirescome from either a separate panel containing a start button, stop button, speed selecting potentiometer, reversing switch and, in some cases, a jog/Run switch, although the latter is not really necessary. When I fitted a VFD to my lathe, I used the carriage mounted start, stop, reverse lever switch and only needed a pot to be added, but decided to add an additional emergency stop switch operating the power contractor. Hitting this, takes all power from the lathe.

Andy

Brian Reay
2018-02-19 22:59:11 UTC
Permalink
Post by Peter Fairbrother
My new Boxford has a three-phase motor, rated 380V in star mode and 220V
in mesh mode.
a) buy a new single-phase motor  or
b) buy an inverter. Can I use an inverter from 230V mains? What is mesh
mode? How to wire it?
The costs are about the same. I don't think there is a lot to be gained
from the speed control of the inverter, changing gear seems quick and easy.
I recall a technique known as the Miller System - I first heard it in
and electrical eng module at Uni but some I knew who had the same
problem mentioned it perhaps 20 years back.

I'd have to look it up to be sure but, as far as I recall, you install 2
caps (similar to used as 'starter' caps).


L1 - L

L2 - N

C1 links L to L3
C2 links N to L3

(caps in series across the supply, L3 to centre point. )


I've never had cause to try it in anger, I think we did a practical
looking at the phase etc at Uni but that was about 40 years back.

I also recall mention of using a 'slave' motor as some way to generate
the required shift but I've no idea how that is configured.
--
Suspect someone is claiming a benefit under false pretences? Incapacity
Benefit or Personal Independence Payment when they don't need it? They
are depriving those in real need!

https://www.gov.uk/report-benefit-fraud
Loading...